When a taxpayer is aggrieved by an order passed by the Assessing Officer (AO) or other tax authorities under the Income Tax Act, 1961, they have the right to file an appeal to the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) (CIT(A)). One of the most critical documents in the appeal process is Form 35.
Form 35 is the prescribed form for filing an appeal before the CIT(A). It serves as a formal application for challenging the decision made by the Assessing Officer, including assessments, penalties, and rectifications. The form plays a crucial role in ensuring that the appeal process is structured, transparent, and compliant with the legal provisions under the Income Tax Act.
In this blog, we will explore the significance of Form 35 in the appeal filing process, its contents, and why it is essential for taxpayers who wish to challenge tax-related orders.
What is Form 35?
Form 35 is a standardized form that taxpayers are required to submit when they file an appeal to the CIT(A). The form is used to challenge various orders passed by the Assessing Officer (AO), such as assessment orders, penalty orders, reassessment orders, or rectification orders.
The Income Tax Department has specifically designed Form 35 to ensure that all necessary details regarding the appeal are provided in a structured manner, including the grounds of appeal, the nature of the dispute, and the evidence supporting the taxpayer’s case.
Key Features of Form 35
1. Official Format for Appeals
Form 35 is the official format mandated by the Income Tax Department. It is designed to standardize the appeal process, ensuring that the taxpayer provides all the required information in a clear and consistent manner.
2. Information Included in Form 35
Form 35 requires the taxpayer to provide essential details such as:
- Personal Information: Name, address, PAN (Permanent Account Number), and contact details of the taxpayer.
- Appeal Information: Details about the order being appealed, such as the order number, date, and the relevant sections of the Income Tax Act.
- Grounds of Appeal: The taxpayer must specify the exact reasons for challenging the order. This includes outlining why the assessment or penalty order is incorrect or unjust.
- Reliefs Sought: The taxpayer must mention the relief they are seeking from the appeal. This could be the reduction or annulment of penalties, adjustments in the assessment, or any other relief related to the tax order.
- Statement of Facts: A summary of the facts of the case, providing a background and explaining the taxpayer’s position regarding the tax dispute.
- Signature: The form must be signed by the taxpayer or their authorized representative.
3. Grounds for Appeal
Form 35 requires the taxpayer to specify grounds of appeal—the specific reasons for disputing the order passed by the Assessing Officer (AO). The grounds should clearly explain why the order is incorrect, citing relevant legal provisions and facts.
Example:
If the Assessing Officer disallowed certain expenses while computing taxable income, the taxpayer might challenge this by providing supporting documents and legal arguments that justify the deductibility of those expenses.
4. Fees for Filing Appeal
Form 35 requires the payment of an appeal fee. The fee depends on the total income of the taxpayer. For example:
- ₹500 for incomes between ₹2 lakh and ₹10 lakh.
- ₹1,000 for incomes exceeding ₹10 lakh.
The appeal fee is a mandatory component of the appeal filing process and must be paid at the time of submitting Form 35.
Why is Form 35 Significant in the Appeal Filing Process?
1. Ensures Proper Documentation
Form 35 is crucial because it ensures that the taxpayer submits the necessary documentation to support the appeal. It serves as a structured request to the CIT(A), providing all the information that the authorities need to process the appeal. This includes personal details, grounds for the appeal, and relief sought.
Without Form 35, the appeal would not be formally considered by the CIT(A), as it is the prescribed form for all income tax appeals. Incomplete or improperly filed forms can lead to the rejection of the appeal.
2. Legal Requirement for Filing an Appeal
Form 35 is not only a procedural document but also a legal requirement under the Income Tax Act. Taxpayers are bound to use this form when filing an appeal to the CIT(A). The failure to submit a complete and accurate Form 35 can result in the rejection of the appeal.
3. Helps Structure the Appeal Process
Form 35 is designed to ensure that the appeal process is clear and well-organized. By following the form’s structure, taxpayers are prompted to provide all the necessary details, which makes it easier for the CIT(A) to evaluate the case and make an informed decision.
Additionally, Form 35 helps ensure that the appeal is processed in an organized manner, reducing the chances of missing critical details or information.
4. Standardization and Transparency
Form 35 helps to standardize the appeal process, making it consistent across all taxpayers. This ensures that all parties involved in the dispute—whether it is the taxpayer, the Assessing Officer, or the CIT(A)—have the same understanding of the appeal’s structure. It promotes transparency by ensuring that all relevant facts, figures, and arguments are presented in a clear and consistent format.
Steps Involved in Filing an Appeal Using Form 35
Step 1: Complete Form 35
The taxpayer must carefully fill out Form 35 with all the required details, including the grounds of appeal, statement of facts, and the relief sought. The form should be signed by the taxpayer or their authorized representative.
Step 2: Attach Supporting Documents
The taxpayer must attach all relevant supporting documents that justify the appeal. This may include:
- Tax payment receipts,
- TDS certificates,
- Incomes and expenses documentation,
- Legal provisions that support the taxpayer’s case.
Step 3: Pay the Appeal Fee
The appeal fee, depending on the taxpayer’s income, should be paid at the time of filing the appeal. A receipt of the payment must be attached to the appeal.
Step 4: File the Appeal with the CIT(A)
The completed Form 35, along with the supporting documents and appeal fee receipt, must be filed with the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) (CIT(A)). Once the appeal is received, the CIT(A) will review it and schedule a hearing, if necessary.
Case Law Reference:
- CIT v. Ashoka Engineering Co. (1992) 194 ITR 645 (SC):
The Supreme Court emphasized the importance of filing Form 35 as part of the appeal process. It highlighted that taxpayers must follow the prescribed format and provide sufficient details to support their claim. - K.P. Varghese v. ITO (1981) 131 ITR 597 (SC):
This case emphasized that Form 35 serves as the legal foundation for filing an appeal and must be filed in accordance with the guidelines set out by the Income Tax Department. The Court also highlighted the importance of the grounds of appeal in forming a strong case.
Conclusion
Form 35 is an essential document in the Income Tax Act’s appeal process. It standardizes the way appeals are filed, ensuring that all the necessary information and supporting documents are provided. By completing Form 35 accurately and adhering to the appeal procedures, taxpayers ensure that their case is heard by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) (CIT(A)) and have a chance to challenge decisions made by the Assessing Officer or other tax authorities.
Additional Resources
Learn more about Tax Provisions on the official Income Tax India website.
Want to consult a professional? Contact us: 09463224996
For more information and related blogs, click here.