The Dispute Resolution Committee (DRC), introduced under Section 245MA of the Income Tax Act, 1961, provides taxpayers with an alternative mechanism for resolving tax disputes. Designed to expedite the resolution of conflicts between taxpayers and the Income Tax Department, the DRC aims to provide a faster, more efficient, and cost-effective means of addressing disputes without going through the prolonged litigation process.

In this blog, we will take a closer look at the process that the Dispute Resolution Committee follows for resolving disputes, ensuring that taxpayers understand each step involved in the procedure.

Overview of the Dispute Resolution Committee (DRC) Process

The process followed by the Dispute Resolution Committee is designed to be straightforward, transparent, and taxpayer-friendly. It allows eligible taxpayers to approach the DRC for resolving disputes related to tax assessments, penalties, and other tax matters. Here’s an outline of the key steps involved in the DRC dispute resolution process:

1. Eligibility Check

Before proceeding with the dispute resolution process, taxpayers must ensure they meet the eligibility criteria outlined under Section 245MA. These conditions include:

• The dispute must be related to a specified order (e.g., draft order of assessment or intimation under Section 143(1)).
• The taxpayer’s total income should not exceed ₹50 lakh, and the total disputed amount should not exceed ₹10 lakh.
• The taxpayer must not be under prosecution or detention under any criminal law related to tax evasion.

If the taxpayer meets these conditions, they can approach the Dispute Resolution Committee for dispute resolution.

2. Filing the Application

Once eligibility is confirmed, the taxpayer can initiate the dispute resolution process by filing an application with the Dispute Resolution Committee. The application must be filed in the prescribed form, typically Form 34BC, which is available on the official website of the Income Tax Department.

The application should contain:

• Details of the dispute, including the specific order the taxpayer is challenging.
• Relevant documentation supporting the taxpayer’s position.
• A fee (which may be nominal, usually around ₹1,000), as prescribed under the rules.

This initial application serves as the formal request to the DRC to begin resolving the dispute.

3. Acknowledgment and Review of the Application

Upon receipt of the application, the Dispute Resolution Committee acknowledges the application and reviews the submitted documents and details of the dispute. At this stage, the DRC assesses whether the application fulfills all the eligibility criteria and whether the dispute falls under its jurisdiction.

If the application is incomplete or does not meet the necessary criteria, the DRC may ask the taxpayer to submit additional information or rectify any discrepancies.

4. Notice of Hearing

Once the application is reviewed and deemed complete, the Dispute Resolution Committee issues a notice of hearing. This notice informs the taxpayer of the date and time for the hearing. The hearing is typically scheduled within a reasonable period after the receipt of the application to ensure a prompt resolution of the dispute.

Taxpayers can choose to attend the hearing in person or opt for virtual hearings, especially if the dispute resolution process is handled digitally.

5. Presentation of the Case

At the hearing, the taxpayer or their authorized representative (e.g., a tax consultant or lawyer) presents the case before the Dispute Resolution Committee. The taxpayer is required to provide:

• A clear explanation of the dispute, including the reason why they disagree with the specified order.
• Supporting documents that validate their position, such as financial statements, tax returns, and communications with the tax authorities.

During the hearing, the DRC may also ask questions to clarify any doubts about the dispute or to gather additional information before making a decision.

6. Interaction with the Tax Authorities

In some cases, the Dispute Resolution Committee may request input from the Income Tax Department. This could involve:

• Clarification from the Assessing Officer or other officials about the tax assessments, penalties, or the basis for the dispute.
• A response from the tax authorities on the issues raised by the taxpayer.

The DRC ensures that both parties — the taxpayer and the tax department — have an opportunity to present their arguments before a decision is made.

7. Decision by the Dispute Resolution Committee

Once the hearing and review of documents are completed, the Dispute Resolution Committee deliberates on the case and issues its decision. This decision is based on the merits of the case, relevant provisions of the Income Tax Act, and the supporting evidence provided by the taxpayer and the tax authorities.

The DRC has the authority to:

• Reduce or waive penalties imposed on the taxpayer.
• Grant immunity from prosecution for offenses related to the disputed matter.
• Modify the original order issued by the tax authorities.

8. Implementation of the Decision

After the DRC has issued its decision, the Assessing Officer is responsible for implementing the decision. The officer is required to take the necessary actions, such as revising the assessment, issuing demand notices, or modifying penalties in accordance with the DRC’s directions.

The taxpayer will receive a final notice from the tax authorities regarding the implementation of the DRC’s decision, which will clarify the amount due (if any) or the outcome of the dispute resolution.

9. Closure of the Dispute

Once the DRC’s decision has been implemented, the dispute is considered resolved, and the process is formally closed. The taxpayer can proceed with any further compliance or make any necessary payments, as directed by the DRC.

Benefits of the Dispute Resolution Committee Process

1. Faster Resolution: The process is significantly faster than going through the traditional court system, reducing the time taxpayers spend in uncertainty.
2. Reduced Costs: Taxpayers do not need to spend significant amounts on legal fees and litigation costs.
3. Penalty Reduction: The DRC has the power to reduce or waive penalties, providing financial relief to taxpayers.
4. Transparency: The process is clear, and taxpayers are informed about the steps involved in dispute resolution.
5. Immunity from Prosecution: In certain cases, the DRC can grant immunity from prosecution, which is a significant benefit for taxpayers who may be concerned about criminal charges related to tax matters.

Conclusion

The Dispute Resolution Committee (DRC) under Section 245MA provides a valuable alternative to the conventional judicial process for resolving tax disputes. By following a straightforward and transparent process, the DRC ensures that disputes are handled efficiently, with reduced penalties and quicker resolutions. The scheme helps reduce the burden on both taxpayers and the judicial system, ensuring fairness and accessibility in resolving tax-related conflicts.

For more information and related blogs, click here.

---

Additional Resources

Learn more about Tax Provisions on the official Income Tax India website.

Want to consult a professional? Contact us: 09463224996

For more information and related blogs, click here.